Blog

Citrix XenApp, OpenGL pass-through and Nvidia GRID cards on Amazon EC2 (G2 Instances)

2015-09-01
/ / /

I’m attempting to do a Proof of Concept (POC) for a client and one of the ideas was to utilize the Amazon EC2 cloud to provide GPU instances to the users for their applications (Maya, SolidWorks, etc.).  In order to understand how GPU sharing works, I setup my home lab to take advantage of these features first, in order to understand how it operates.

Citrix provides documentation on setting up the GPU sharing.  For my test, I’m doing this on a bare metal Citrix server.  Essentially, the notes state that OpenGL is automatically shared and enabled and special steps must be taken for DirectX, OpenCL, CUDA and Windows Server 2012.  To enable GPU sharing for XenApp for these features, the following registry file will enable these:

Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00
Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Graphics Helper] “DirectX”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Wow6432Node\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Graphics Helper] “DirectX”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Multiple Monitor Hook] “EnableWPFHook”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Wow6432Node\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Multiple Monitor Hook] “EnableWPFHook”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Graphics Helper] “CUDA”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Wow6432Node\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Graphics Helper] “CUDA”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Graphics Helper] “OpenCL”=dword:00000001
[HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Wow6432Node\Citrix\CtxHook\AppInit_Dlls\Graphics Helper] “OpenCL”=dword:00000001

In addition to this registry file, for Server 2012, the following Group Policy object is required:

  • On Windows Server 2012, Remote Desktop Services (RDS) sessions on the RD Session Host server use the Microsoft Basic Render Driver as the default adapter. To use the GPU in RDS sessions on Windows Server 2012, enable the Use the hardware default graphics adapter for all Remote Desktop Services sessions setting in the group policy Local Computer Policy > Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Remote Desktop Services > Remote Desktop Session Host > Remote Session Environment.

My initial setup is a Q87M-E system with a Intel 4771 and onboard graphics.  My system is setup with Windows 2012 R2 with Citrix XenApp 7.6.

Launching an ICA session to the XenApp 7.6 server results in:

 

 

We have OpenGL working, DirectX 11, and OpenCL (the onboard Intel GPU’s do not support CUDA).  So we have a full, working implementation of GPU sharing in a ICA session on a XenApp server.

But the onboard Intel graphics card will not get the me the performance I want.  I had a Nvidia GTX 670 video card on hand to see if I can get better 3D performance.  I installed that card in the system, installed the video drivers and checked the results.

 

Where did my OpenGL go?  Everything else is working correctly; Direct3D, CUDA, OpenCL, but not OpenGL.  My understanding from Nvidia is that OpenGL should just be ‘passed through’ by Citrix.  I know that it *does* pass-through because we, literally, just saw it with the onboard Intel GPU and the Intel drivers.

My next thought is maybe it had to do with the drivers?  Maybe if I tried the Quadro drivers?  It turns out Nvidia has released special Quadro drivers that enable OpenGL in a RDP session. Maybe if I modified the INF to add my GTX670 to these special drivers I could get OpenGL to work?

 

It did not work.  OpenGL remained disabled in RDP/ICA sessions.

Suspecting Nvidia is doing some form of detection that is disabling OpenGL (it’s probably considered a ‘pro’-feature) I acquired a Quadro FX5800 and using the *same* modified Quadro drivers, these were my results:

 

OpenGL is now working!!

Ok, so, at this point I know how to enable GPU sharing for Citrix XenApp, I know how to check and verify it’s functionality, and I know that different Nvidia cards can have OpenGL enabled or disabled but am not sure if it’s the driver that matters or the hardware.  If it’s the hardware I’m a bit surprised Intel would incorporate hardware accelerated OpenGL into ICA sessions for their consumer pieces but Nvidia would not for their discrete cards.  To *attempt* to test this I went and got the oldest driver I could find that would support a FX5800:

Sure enough, it works.

My last thought is maybe Nvidia has it hard coded somewhere to check for a string or a specific ‘type’ of video card and, if found, enable OpenGL?

My thinking is that the Nvidia drivers are doing some kind of detection and making a determination between a console session and all others.  If I’m lucky, maybe they only implemented this in their *newer* drivers, maybe after they started the RDS OpenGL acceleration…

To test this theory I went and grabbed the oldest driver I could find for my GTX 670 that would work on Windows 2012R2.  327.23.

 

Well now…  OpenGL is working.  This is interesting.  And leads evidence that OpenGL is being disabled in ICA via the driver.  I attempted to find when OpenGL *stopped* working.

331.82 –> Works, and now with OpenGL 4.4

337.88  -> Works

340.52 -> No OpenGL.  This driver (340.52) is now the first gaming driver *After* the “OpenGL on RDS release” (340.43).  It appears something on or after the 340.XX branch is disabling OpenGL in ICA sessions.

At the same time I was testing my Nvidia gaming GPU on my home lab, I was testing Amazon.  The GPU instance that Amazon provides utilize the Nvidia GRID K520 card as a vGPU.  This card is marketed as a ‘GRID Gaming‘ card.  I setup this instance with Citrix XenApp and, at the time, used the latest driver (347.70).  At the time of this testing, this was my 3rd rebuild of this instance so I went with Server 2008 because my previous 2 builds were 2012 and I was convinced I was doing something wrong.  The OS shouldn’t matter, but I’m noting it here.

347.70 –> No OpenGL (just like the gaming card):

Knowing that downgrading the gaming card’s driver worked, I installed the oldest driver I could for the K520:

320.59 –> OpenGL Works!

Just like the gaming card.  I suspect the K520 will have the same issue as the GTX 670, and that any driver after 340.XX will disable OpenGL in a ICA session.  Unfortunately, the Grid K520 appears to only have 3 drivers to chose from, 320.59, 335.35, and 347.70.  To finish this testing I will test with 335.35:

OpenGL Works!  So it appears driver 340 and newer will disable OpenGL for ICA sessions across various types of Nvidia GPU’s, but not Quadro’s..

If you want OpenGL to work on Amazon EC2 instances, you must (at the time of this writing…  hopefully Nvidia corrects this over sight for all cards – consumer and not) you must use a driver older than 340.

Read More

Citrix Seamless Flags and their impact

2015-07-23
/ / /

While investigating a performance issue with an application in our Citrix farm a curiosity was discovered when someone opened up Process Explorer and found the CPU utilization on the server was much higher than expected or reported by various monitoring tools we use.

Examining what was utilizing the CPU we found the process ‘winlogon.exe’ was consuming nearly the entire difference between Process Explorer and Task Manager.

Process Explorer allows us to dive ‘deeper’ into the process to determine the thread that is utilizing our CPU.
twi3.dll is a Citrix file.  Click ‘Module’ and getting properties gives us more information about the file and its purpose.

“Seamless 2.0 Host Agent – main component”


 Now that we have an idea of the purpose of twi3.dll is, we can being to test why it’s consuming so much CPU.  Citrix has options for modifying the behaviour of twi3.dll via “Seamless Flags”.
For our environment we had the following set:
I experimented with modifying each value to determine what the impact on the CPU on the twi3.dll threads would experience.
To that end, you can modify these values immediately and they take effect on the next session connect (but does not impact existing sessions).  With that, here were my results:
Lower numbers for CPU% are better and per user.  More CPU’s actually lower the maximum % winlogon.exe can consume, for this test it was done with a 6 core CPU.  Less CPU’s and the maximum % increases..  I imagine this is due to a thread limit or some such?  
The values that had the most impact on CPU utilization were the lowest values for the WorkerWaitInterval or WorkerFullCheckInterval followed by Disable Active Accessibility Hook.
So what does WorkerWaitInterval / WorkerFullCheckInterval do?
WORKER WAIT INTERVAL / WORKER FULL CHECK INTERVAL
Explanation: This update addresses a custom application’s performance when run seamlessly. Some applications appeared to be slower to respond when performing actions such as moving, resizing, or closing windows. This fix introduces two new registry settings that allow administrators to configure an explicit time interval for the seamless engine mechanism to monitor when changes take place in the seamless applications.

For both values, a larger size slows responsiveness but improves scalability; a smaller size increases responsiveness but decreases scalability slightly. The level of scalability depends on several factors, such as hardware sizing, types of applications, network performance, and number of users. 

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINESYSTEMCurrentControlSetControlCitrixwfshellTWI Value Name: WorkerWaitInterval
Type: REG_DWORD
Value: 0
Value: (Values are between 5 – 500; the default is 50.)

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINESYSTEMCurrentControlSetControlCitrixwfshellTWI Value Name: WorkerFullCheckInterval
Type: REG_DWORD
Value: (Values are between 50 – 5000; the default is 500.)

For the graph above, the WorkerWaitInterval and WorkerFullCheckInterval defined in milliseconds, when they are a low value, forces the seamless engine to monitor for changes at a higher pace.  This consumes additional CPU cycles.  
For our environment we encountered issues as user count increased.  It turns out, as each user logged on they consumed a fairly constant amount of CPU.  The winlogon.exe process for the server in the screenshot averaged around 0.8% CPU per user, with 35 users that’s 28% of the CPU no longer available.  So why does Task Manager not display these values?  The author of Process Explorer has the answer:
The configured time range we configured were 5ms so the threads executing have a good chance being before or after the timer tick of 15.6ms.
So this poses a question of what *should* the values be?  Citrix Adaptive Display technology has a maximum frame rate of 30 for XenApp 6.5 and a maximum of 60 for XenApp 7+.  Potentially, I think to achieve these frame rates a value of 16 for XA7 or 33 for XA65 could be set.  If the FPS is set to a lower maximum, it would probably make more sense to do the math for that maximum FPS?
Further testing may be needed here.

Lastly, if you do not use Seamless Flags, e.g., if you use Shift F1 to switch to Window’ed Mode then Winlogon.exe will use no CPU for twi3.dll.  You also get the same results with RDP, no CPU being used.

Read More

AppV5 – Virtualizing and running Local Services stand-alone

2015-07-10
/ / /

AppV5 allows you to virtualize Services that run under the LocalService account.  The issue I’ve seen with this approach is AppV5 will load the service for a user upon environment launch (which is good for VDI / desktop deployments) and the service will terminate upon that AppV environment exiting.  For remote desktop / Citrix XenApp deployments, this can be a big bother.  If the service is required for running the application the standard answer is to extract it and install it using DeploymentConfig.xml or some other on application publish.

But what if you have a service that is NOT required to run an application, just needs to run in the background, AND can run as the LocalService?  This service would be prime for being virtualized!

Do I have an example of such an application?  Why yes I do.

Epic SystemPulse is an application that captures performance information and uploads it to a DB.  It only runs under a LocalService account.

Using my Citrix PVS Sequencer, here is how I sequenced it:

These next screenshots illustrate the simplicity of this application:

Virtual Registry Hive For Epic SystemPulse

 

All files required for Epic SystemPulse

 

Lastly, the single service we need running

Now, the problem.

I am running this service on a RDS/XenApp server.  This service needs to run while an application, Epic Hyperspace, is running.  My first thought was the use a connection group so that whenever Hyperspace is launched, SystemPulse will launch with it.

This, initially, worked.  The first user who launched HyperSpace also had SystemPulse running at the same time.  Subsequent user whom launched HyperSpace, had their SystemPulse service start and terminate, with the first service continuing to run.  It looked like a success!

Second user launches app, SystemPulse (EpicSvcMaster.exe & EpicSvcHost.exe) starts and terminates, the original processes still running.

Eventually, that first user logged off.  And the SystemPulse processes exited with it.

I thought being SYSTEM processes they were started in some way that a ‘SYSTEM’ process wouldn’t terminate willy-nilly.  This is not the case.  A quick test of ‘get-appvclientpackage’ shows the package as ‘In Use’, signifying that AppV5 is tracking the processes.  The users logging off will turn that ‘True’ into a ‘False’.

Now, we had to wait until the next user started the application to have the service start back up.  This was an unacceptable solution.

But we know that this AppV5 package will work as a service.  We can reap all the benefits of AppV; we can deploy this package on a whim, it’s not a local/permanent install, it works!  So now the question becomes how can we keep these advantages and what are the drawbacks?

The first drawback I encountered was ‘how do I open a AppV Virtual Environment (appvve) so this service will start?’

I tried several things.

I created a script/scheduled task that would check to see if the process was running and if not, open a appvve.  This failed.  I tried this using the LOCAL SERVICE to start my script to open my environment and it would not.  I tried using the SYSTEM account and it failed.  It turns out you can’t use either of these accounts to open a appvve.

With this failing, I moved to another method.  AppV has the ability to start a script upon application publishing, could I use this to start my service when the application is published?  It turns out that the account that runs when this context is started is the SYSTEM account, and it failed same as the scheduled task.

At this point I figured my problem is the account I’m trying to open the appvve with.  I need to launch it with a service account.  My first attempt I made a script with a hard-coded username/password string with PSEXEC.exe to open my appvve.  I put this script in deploymentconfig.xml.

And it worked!  It opened my appvve environment, the services started, and everything looked great! The only issue I had now is the hard-coded username/password combo.  There is no way having that would be acceptable in a plain text file.

So I created a exe with AutoIt, ‘RunAsWait.exe’.

It may not be the most secure thing when compiled, but internally it’s good enough…
With this I set my deploymentconfig.xml with the program and arguments I was looking for:

The CMD file looked like so:

With this, my service will start upon application publish.

I set it to launch a exe that gets installed with the package (SystemPulseConfigEditor.exe) as I needed a unique name I could key in on to determine if the package started successfully.  This has a drawback though, the exe I chose has a GUI and I launch the process with -WindowStyle Hidden; if the service crashes, this EXE prompts for attention.  When RDP’ed into a server this notice comes up as “Interactive Service” something-or-other and clicking on it brings this exe visible.  I have considered making a AutoIT app that has no GUI and just sits in the background doing nothing, but time has not permitted me this yet.  Sometimes the SystemPulse service will crash so I added the /RESTART to this batch file to get it to kick off.  By removing the package then ‘rsync’ing with the publishing server we trigger PublishPackage script which launches the service.

Read More

Citirx Universal Print Server – More Zebra label printer troubleshooting tips

2015-07-09
/ / /

Continuing on my previous post I was troubleshooting some issues with some Zebra label printers.  I thought I had it working by switching the rendering path to XPS.  This did allow the printers to print – or so I thought.  It turns out that some of the older Zebra printers we had (LP-2824) were not printing the labels correctly, a newer LP-2824 PLUS was printing correctly.  The LP-2824’s were scaling the labels down to 20% for some reason.

In order to capture this so I wasn’t wasting legions of paper, you need to turn on ‘Keep printed documents’ in the ‘Advanced’ tab of your printer.

On your print server (not the client), this option will store the spooler files (SPL) here:
C:\windows\system32\spool\printers

Generally, there are two types of formats encapsulated in a SPL file, RAW and EMF.  Citrix provides a EMF reader in ‘cpviewer.exe’.  This utility is located in Program Files (x86) and is used like this:
“C:\Program Files (x86)\Citrix\ICA Client\cpviewer.exe” C:\00167.SPL

This will bring up a preview.

I setup two scenarios for printing.

Scenario 1 – Printing directly to the print queue with the “ZDesigner LP 2824” driver
Scenario 2 – Printing through the Citrix Universal Print Driver via UPS.

Trying both scenarios caused my cpviewer.exe to hang/freeze.  This is where I learned the cpviewer utility ONLY works with EMF-type SPL files.  Trying to read a RAW file will cause it to hang.  I was able to verify it was RAW by looking at the preferences for the print driver:

 

It turns out that ‘Printer default’ and ‘Raw’ are the same value.  Selecting ‘Enhanced metafile’ and reprinting to that printer created the proper SPL file that I could open in cpviewer.  With this I could now see the issue the users were reporting:
Left print is direct to the printer, on the right is through Citrix UPD.  I’m missing the barcode on the right.
With the ZDesigner driver, if I forced the ‘Enhanced metafile’ in the preferences, all the Citrix UPD prints lost their barcodes.  If I set the Citrix UPD to XPS and the Zebra on RAW it printed with a barcode, but the scale was still horribly off (same as the picture above).
I tried adjusting almost every option available on the ZDesigner side, from the paper size, dpi, different stocks, etc.  It consistently turned out scaled down.  If I adjusted the margins it would move the graphic around but nothing would enable the graphic to be the correct size.  I looked at the Citrix UPD advanced settings and changed the paper height, width, dpi, scale, print quality, orientation, etc. Not a single affect was made except for orientation.  At least I knew the settings were applying because of that.  Orientation didn’t make a difference in the scale, just made the tiny graphic vertical instead of horizontal.  At this point I decided it had to be driver related.  I downloaded two different sets of ZDesigner Zebra drivers for the LP-2824, the latest and the last major version release, installed both but the exact same issue still persisted.
Searching for others that may have had the same issue or something similar I found a link to another company providing Zebra label printer drivers, Seagull Scientific.
With nothing else to lose, I installed and configured those drivers per the original spec for media, etc.  Then I printed and checked the SPL file:
Success!  Barcode is present!  Scale is correct!  Format is pure EMF from Citrix UPD to barcode printer, no XPS anywhere, no RAW anywhere!
All that said, this is a ringing endorsement for what Seagull Scientific has done with the Zebra Barcode printers.  Their drivers *just work* as opposed to the ZDesigner drivers.  If you need to print to older Zebra printers, heck, probably for all Zebra printers, use Seagull’s drivers.
Read More

Citrix Universal Print Server – Troubleshooting printing blank pages or inconsistent printing.

2015-07-08
/ / /

We have an application that is hard coded to map printers via a UNC path.  This is the bane of a Citrix admin whom wants to minimize the number of drivers on the XenApp server as each UNC connection can prompt for a driver install (this is how our environment is configured).  User’s click ‘Install Driver’ and boom, your Citrix server has another driver on your server and another point of possible instability.

Citrix has attempted to solve this using the Universal Print Driver (UPD) but this just maps printers from your local system to the Citrix session.  Each printer is given a unique name and each queue is given a unique port as well.

Unfortunately, this makes it impossible for our hardcoded app to use a consistent printer as these queues and names do not exist unless we install them locally.  If the program displayed a simple print dialog this wouldn’t be an issue but it is not coded that way.

Fortunately, Citrix has come up with a *fairly* elegant solution: Citrix Universal Print Server (UPS).  How this works is it forces the mapped network printers to come across using the Citrix Universal Print Driver.  There are two parts to this, the Citrix UPS and the Universal Print Client (UPC).  The UPS goes on your Windows Print Server and the UPC goes on your XenApp servers.

XenApp server

Windows Print Server

To enable the UPS functionality and have your network printers use the Citrix UPD you need to enable a Citrix group policy object on the XenApp server (that’s why you see Citrix Group Policy Management (x64) 1.7.0.0).  If you have a version older than 1.7.0.0 then you won’t have the relevant policy available to you:

Setting this setting to either “Enabled” setting turns on the UPC feature.  For any network printer that you map to the Windows Print Server with the UPS it will use the Citrix UPD.  To verify this, go to your XenApp server and map a printer from the UPS and look at the driver.

UPS in Action.  Note the driver for the network printer is “Citrix Universal Printer”

Ok, so with UPS installed and working we should be good right?

Right?  🙂

Well…  It turns out that our label printers were printing out blanks with Citrix UPS.  To determine if it was truly the UPS causing my problem I enabled printer mapping, added the network printer locally complete with the native driver and launched my app.  This mapped my local printer into my session with the Citrix UPD.  I tried printing and…   nothing.  Just a blank label came out.

To troubleshoot this process, Zebra actually has a good document on determining if your printer is rendering/printing correctly by printing to a text file.  If you have a new enough Zebra printer installed you can actually use it to ‘preview’ the label so you don’t waste paper, AND you don’t need have a label printer physically present beside you.  Older Zebra’s don’t seem to have this functionality (LP 2824 I’m looking at you!).  I had a PDF file I tried printing from PDF Architect that output to the text file.

So, what did my print job look like?

CT~~CD,~CC^~CT~
^XA
^PW445
^PQ1,0,1,Y^XZ

What does this look like on the Zebra?


Well then. Curiously, if I printed the same document from Adobe Reader it came out like this:

CT~~CD,~CC^~CT~
^XA
^PW446
^FO0,0^GFA,23296,23296,00056,:Z64:
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:DA24
^PQ1,0,1,Y^XZ

Label looks good
So, when we print from Adobe Reader we get the expected result.  But if we print from PDF Architect or directly from our application we don’t get anything and the data is missing entirely!  This is a strange issue indeed.  The Zebra driver shows its supported formats:
RAW or EMF…  The Citrix UPD has two modes, EMF (standard “Citrix Universal Print Driver”) or XPS (“Citrix XPS Universal Print Driver”).  I would assume EMF to EMF would be the way to go?
By utilizing the ‘printer mapped’ UPD, avoiding the UPS, we can enable ‘Print Preview’ functionality and look at the EMF file as it’s placed in the print queue.  Here’s is what I see:
Adobe Reader on the left, PDF Architect on the right
Well, there is content being sent to the print queue from both applications.  Adobe Reader looked slightly heavier in its lines vs. PDF Architect but both SPL files had content.  This is still very confusing why Adobe Reader actually prints but PDF Architect does not.  Maybe it’s in the way Adobe Reader processes its file?  I don’t know.  Maybe there’s a way to modify EMF on Citrix?  It turns out, you can.
Citrix offers the ability to modify the way it’s EMF driver works by reprocessing it.  You can enable this feature via Group Policy.  
Reprocess EMF for printer
Did it make a difference?  No.  Still a blank page/no content for PDF Architect, Adobe Reader prints out fine.  
At this point I was at my ropes end and decided to grasp at straws.  
The Citrix UPS also allows you use the XPS driver instead of the EMF driver.  This would force a completely different rendering path, XPS -> XPS to GDI -> EMF -> GDI/DDI Driver -> PDL Print Device.  We know it has to go this way as the Zebra driver only does EMF or RAW and the UPD will only output EMF files.  To enable XPS printing I changed the Universal Driver Preference to favour XPS.

 I reprinted to XPS from both PDF Architect and Adobe Reader.  Again, Adobe Reader showed up darker but again there is content to be printed from both spools.

PDF Architect on the left, Adobe Reader on the right
And what did the print queue show?
PDF Architect:

CT~~CD,~CC^~CT~^XA^PW446^FO0,0^GFA,23296,23296,00056,:Z64: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:EC01^PQ1,0,1,Y^XZ

Adobe Reader:

CT~~CD,~CC^~CT~^XA^PW446^FO0,0^GFA,23296,23296,00056,:Z64:eJztmkloE1EYx99MJnHE1CSCVgSbBEVxQy81WtBqpZViEREUitYISsGDeBAsepnXGhcUN+xBEDXFS/FgsaKHSiEIIiiYVBEqGlLXlmJd2yRVk/FNlppM0mQSRS38f8yWN/PL9711cgghAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAACYo4mLLuguigSyr2zDkfa8L9oc1iiV+6eTQa2fpvd59O/aGmzqWafQa/NL5jpFA6dtnQ4/2hIP9Wr0Y5kIeJqRSVhFVF8ShKk+Vky15YWC7ENsIxxxOHe9fe2LSK3lyXV8hVcuPF60tKJ7R6dVPkd7u/y5ribfk8aC/mDznNjxIesNuYbRCX3FwpZ1oyPM4oQnvsudI2039yY2mGwXVr7A8NXvlh7pyefrNzGmOPs3wHN8GEldimjc14fmYd8x5IMOrDKQN30jsGPpVwG5HWGEks368Kk8+lmR6/dZkaRdeVZLpkeweZSfWbZSmxWOfBMo8yuLRbF6M7tqtp4rJ82Nt6Mfv1K8gT0zxuu7cZZIoxjxRc7w5Dz8q3ui2mrzxdKn93hfPU77YmMcrb9qlDBCnFJJkaczLXz+H9Eo5UWVjB1upr8XafXTWYM1z72eXqdUV9zy56qes2DbrJr70h2Hq9sZaKeQqCedsF6HdbWp3EzMXLqwfJq3vm3S/j3mfiO3D8ipH9TzdtRpuhk9wLHQRE+GO7qxqU3srlO8XGYTMZB1pk6P80qjB5DVwUY9x1VcjmUK5M+41L9VeZXKWBeRfM1GZcXKEfZaUCSkpRdm9/ORrT1W76Ov4FUqbZO8HGvfYDEzxKBUodW1vGWhmPduc6Y2hxLNHZndW9gStPlkXse629shk3PUzLU97ydkv9voyc+8Zfvq5N5Z6E7utyRPNLXZuhpme5s0WwcIZc3piijfzxAKVN1lLPJ+VX829s5Kgrq9MKOOGNeZpyxif43q6kDM+JGLjRWLTMCJLTZLUFFu5lTtsD2XxNI0XmpnnlpHvHuVyGlsJ53f6b8ndl8ae0kdut74gmuqXhpA451uX1CTfTLneR2KOeJP/XJ5/3aNJj/7fecKb0N4YBXnFvo+siZ+cCQJaPQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAEw1P4m/IhRK4erYo78rh4uIZirIAAAAAAAAAAAAwcfkJ2Wk8DQ==:9DEC^PQ1,0,1,Y^XZ

Success!  It appears changing the rendering path to XPS works in resolving the data not getting rendered.  When printed from the application with the EMF driver and a blank page was spit out, I tried again with the XPS driver and it worked successfully:

CT~~CD,~CC^~CT~^XA^PW446^FO0,0^GFA,23296,23296,00056,:Z64: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:7C79^PQ1,0,1,Y^XZ

To that end, I am concluding my work.  Unfortunately, I do not know why Adobe Reader always worked without issue where two other applications did not.  When on EMF mode, I could send a test page to the printer via print properties and it would have the full content, I could also print from notepad to the EMF queue and it worked just fine.  For some reason, whatever path PDF Architect and my other application uses to print to the EMF driver just didn’t work.  The Citrix EMF Viewer would display content, implying there is data.  I do know there are several versions of EMF (NT EMF 1.003-8) you can choose on the printer processor properties, but it appears the Zebra driver ignores those settings in favour of it’s selection I posted previously.  Forcing a different print processor (HP or Lexmark) in addition to an incompatible print processor type (TEXT/XPS) the Zebra driver will still work.  So maybe it’s a EMF version compatibility thing and whatever version Adobe Reader is passing works?  
Read More

AppV5 – Prelaunch Script for Citrix XenApp 6.5 applications with varying environments

2015-07-07
/ / /

We utilize a lot of pre-launch scripts for our AppV5 applications that we use in our Citrix XenApp 6.5 environment.  They become a necessity very quickly as AppV5 stores the executable down a very long path.  Citrix XenApp 6.5 has a maximum launch string of 160 characters and this maximum prevents a lot of applications from working if they require parameters to be passed to them.  An example looks like this:

This launch path is too long for XenApp 6.5.  The string will be truncated and the program will fail to launch properly.   We have several environments that work with the same package files so we set them as variables.  To get this package to launch properly we create a prelaunch script that looks like so:
At this point we set our application to point to this CMD file.
And the application will launch with the shorter string with the ability for us to change the environment and location quickly and easily.
Read More

AppV5 – Recipe for Epic 2012

2015-07-03
/ / /

Prerequisites:
AppV5 – Sequencing first steps

Recipe:

I create install.cmd files for all of my applications so that, if required in the future, I can re-sequence an application quickly completely through script or via one of those ‘PowerShell AppV5 automated GUI’s’.

install.cmd

Supplemental files:
None
 
 
1) Select ‘install.cmd’ and click ‘Next’
2) Name the package and click ‘Next’
3) Let the install script do its thing (note the clock)…

4) AppV5 – Post install sequencing steps

5) Review for any extra registry keys/files (generally there are none or very few) and remove and save the package.

6) In order for Epic to launch in a reasonable amount of time, registry staging must be done.  Without a pre-executed registry staging, first launch performance of Epic can take hundreds of seconds.

Read More

AppV5 – Recipe for ScreenTest III

2015-07-03
/ / /

This is the most recent app I sequenced and a good template for how I am going to do my recipes.

Prerequisites:
AppV5 – Sequencing first steps

Recipe:

I create install.cmd files for all of my applications so that, if required in the future, I can re-sequence an application quickly completely through script or via one of those ‘PowerShell AppV5 automated GUI’s’.

install.cmd

Supplemental files:
odbc.reg
 
 
 
1) Select ‘install.cmd’ and click ‘Next’
2) Name the package and click ‘Next’
3) Let the install script do its thing…

4) AppV5 – Post install sequencing steps

5) Review for any extra registry keys/files (generally there are none or very few) and remove and save the package.

Read More

AppV5 – Post install sequencing steps

2015-07-03
/ / /

1) Check ‘I am finished installing’ and click ‘Next’

2) Wait out the ‘Collecting system changes’…

3) You may choose to ‘select’ your application and click ‘Run Selected‘ then click ‘Next’

4) Click ‘Next’

5) Select ‘Customize’ and click ‘Next’

6) Select ‘Force applications to be fully downloaded’ and click ‘Next’

7) Select ‘Allow this package to run on any operating system’ and click ‘Next’

8) Select ‘Continue to modify this package without saving using the package editor’ and click ‘Next’

9) Click ‘Close’

Read More

AppV5 – Sequencing first steps

2015-07-03
/ / /

I follow a specific pattern when sequencing my applications.  I’m going to put the same first steps for every application I sequence here.

1) Open the ‘Microsoft Application Virtualization Sequencer’ and select the menu ‘File’ then ‘Load Template…’

2) Browse to and select your template.

3) Click OK

4) Click ‘Create a New Virtual Application Package’

5) Click ‘Next’

6) Click ‘Next’

7) Choose ‘Standard Application’ and click ‘Next’

Read More